“My website ranks, but nobody asks us for a quote.” Before paying for an audit, finish that sentence with a product, a market and a date. “Our pump pages still rank for our name, but enquiries for chemical dosing pumps fell after the July redesign” is a problem an auditor can investigate.
An SEO audit follows buyers from a search query to a landing page. An AI visibility audit examines what an assistant says when a buyer describes a requirement, which suppliers appear and what sources support the answer. Choose the investigation that can explain the symptom.
Start with the symptom
| What you observe | First investigation | Evidence to request |
|---|---|---|
| Enquiries dropped after a redesign | SEO and conversion-path review | Old and new landing URLs, query clicks before and after, and a successful test enquiry in the CRM |
| Visitors still arrive and forms work, but buyers say they found rival suppliers through AI | AI visibility audit | Dated buyer prompts, answers, linked sources and a record of how often results varied |
| The CRM suddenly labels every lead “general enquiry” | Tracking and sales operations | Follow one test submission from the service page to the CRM service field |
Two sample findings for the same manufacturer
1. SEO finding, illustrative –
A buyer searching for a stainless-steel dosing pump reaches a general pumps page. The previous product URL redirects there, even though a replacement product page exists. The useful deliverable names the affected URLs, identifies the equivalent destination and assigns someone to update the redirect and internal links. It also says how to check which page receives clicks after the fix.
2. AI finding, illustrative –
A buyer asks for suppliers that support food-grade applications in western India. In the recorded answers, an assistant cites a competitor’s application page. Your company appears only when the prompt includes your name. Check whether your public pages actually document the materials, applications and service region in the question. Publish evidence your engineers can stand behind. Repeat the unbranded test and record what changed. A single answer establishes what happened on that run.
What should you receive for the fee?
Ask the provider to show a sample finding, its underlying evidence, the person responsible for the fix and the retest. For an AI audit, ask whether the provider distinguishes a link to your article from a recommendation to contact your company. For Google AI features, ordinary search eligibility still matters. Google’s AI search guidance
If you can identify the week search enquiries fell, start with an SEO review. If customers describe finding their shortlist through assistants, bring their actual wording to a generative search visibility review. When comparing providers, use the agency briefing template to give each the same problem.
